May 7, 2012 05:38

[UPDATE: A little after 1 p.m. Monday, LDOE sent the document in question to The Independent. Read the federal letter (peer review notes are not included) to LDOE here, and check back with The Ind's website for updates on what the letter means for Louisiana's plan for flexibility in federal accountability standards.]

[UPDATE: A little after 1 p.m. Monday, LDOE sent the document in question to The Independent. Read the federal letter (peer review notes are not included) to LDOE here, and check back with The Ind's website for updates on what the letter means for Louisiana's plan for flexibility in federal accountability standards.]

If the critiques included in Louisiana's feedback letter from the U.S. Department of Education regarding the state's No Child Left Behind waiver application are as minimal as what state Superintendent John White outlines in a Monday Times-Picayune article, one has to wonder why the Louisiana Department of Education has been so hell bent on keeping the public record a secret.

As The Independent first reported in its Wednesday blog, "LDOE foot dragging tramples transparency," the 26 states applying for flexibility under the stringent federal No Child Left Behind requirements have been put on notice by the U.S. Department of Education that certain components of their waiver applications must be modified before gaining final approval. It's a critical part of the process for states seeking to opt out of the law's cumbersome achievement benchmarks and accountability systems, as the feedback from the feds outlines both strengths and weaknesses in the alternative plans offered up by each state on how to improve the quality of public education without the red tape attached to the signature federal education law.

Louisiana is among the 26 states (plus Washington, D.C.) requesting a waiver from NCLB provisions, and the application submitted by the Louisiana Department of Education is not immune to the federal scrutiny other state applications are receiving. The U.S. Education Department sent critique letters to states April 17, but the contents of Louisiana's letter - i.e. the deficiencies in our state's alternative plan for achieving higher academic performance - are still being shielded from the public.

After almost an entire week of ignoring The Independent's repeated records requests (inquiries that LDOE initially tried to claim were not available for public release), the newspaper reached out to Board of Elementary and Secondary Education members Lottie Beebe, Penny Dastugue and Holly Boffy seeking help in our struggles to obtain the public document. We also spoke with the state Attorney General's Office to see what remedies are available to the paper in trying to compel LDOE to comply with state law.

LDOE spokeswoman Rene Greer contacted The Ind Friday afternoon and said via email that "information related to the NCLB waiver will be available to you on Monday."

"Does that work? If so, I'm assuming you want me to provide you with the information electronically, correct?" Greer says in the email.

In The Independent's response to Greer, we asked the department to send the document Friday afternoon and not wait until Monday because LDOE has been in violation of state sunshine laws since Friday, April 27.  

Greer has yet to respond to the newspaper's Friday afternoon email. She has also failed to return phone calls and emails sent Monday morning. As of noon Monday, The Independent still does not have the public record in hand.

But a report published Monday morning on The Times-Picayune's website includes extensive details and comments from John White regarding the same federal feedback this newspaper is fighting to obtain, though it appears The T-P's info came directly from White:

The state plans to release the federal government's initial feedback Monday, along with its response. Overall, the feds praised Louisiana's strategy for imposing standards to ensure the state's pupils are college- or career-ready; for intervening with failing schools using the state-run Recovery School District; and for supporting local districts.

But the state also faced some pointed questions about its accountability system that might force some big changes. Among the most significant issues outlined by state Superintendent John White in an interview Friday, Louisiana will almost certainly have to drop using a standardized exam given last year to about 11,000 students with special needs known as the Louisiana Alternate Assessment 2, or LAA2, after the next academic year.
Read the full T-P article here.

The Independent will update this blog and publish the federal letter to LDOE in its entirety as soon as we receive it.

Also from Heather Miller

Should Democrats dump Dixie? DEC 17 Blogger Bob Mann gives his two cents on the question being discussed among tight-pants-bushy-beard-hat-on-in-the-house northern liberals who were disgusted by Mary's defeat. In a round-about way, he's seeking to remind them that the pendulum always swings back. Must-read story about Janzen Jackson DEC 17 This post on Vice Sports is an in-depth look at the life of Janzen Jack

Read the flipping paper