Whitney executives eligible for severance payments once deal with Hancock Holding is complete. By Rebecca Mowbray
When Hancock Holding Co. revealed Dec. 22 that it was merging with Whitney Holding Corp., it announced that it would repay Whitney's $300 million in Troubled Asset Relief Program money at the deal closing to give the combined company a fresh start.
But that plan also may open the door for Whitney executives to receive generous severance payments that would not have otherwise been allowed under TARP if they leave the combined company.
Like many companies, Whitney has "change in control" agreements with executives spelling out their severance packages if they are terminated because their company is acquired by or merges with a competitor.
Under the terms of the U.S. Department of Treasury's bailout programs, TARP companies aren't allowed to pay severance or change in control payments to the top ten employees.
But if a bank that didn't take TARP money, such as Hancock, buys a TARP bank, something known as the "white knight" rule says that the Treasury's executive compensation rules don't apply.
This development does not sit well with Whitney shareholders like John Cummings, who describes himself as "heartbroken" over New Orleans' signature bank having to sell out to a smaller competitor because of what he sees as bad decisions by Whitney executives.
"That seems off that someone who participated in the failure of the bank could be rewarded for destroying the bank," Cummings said. "I would hope that executive officers (would) just refuse them. Many of their actions and inactions have caused hundreds of millions of dollars of losses for the stockholders."
Cummings noted that Whitney chairman and chief executive John Hope told shareholders at the contentious 2009 shareholder meeting that he accepted "full responsibility for our performance."
For its part, Hancock seems to expect that change of control payments will be made. "Each of Whitney's executive officers has an employment contract that provides severance benefits in the event of a qualified termination' in connection with a change in control. The integration process could result in qualified terminations' which could trigger severance payments that could result in significant expense and in the loss of experienced officers," according to the discussion about risk factors associated with the merger in Hancock's draft proxy about the deal.
The idea behind change in control agreements is to make sure that executives are taken care of so they won't be worried about their own future when they should be concerned with doing what's best for the company and its shareholders. Such an agreement, for example, could help ensure that an executive wouldn't act in his own self-interest and turn down an opportunity for a merger that would be beneficial to shareholders because he's worried that his job could get cut in the consolidation.
Change of control agreements also have become a tool for recruiting and retaining executives on the theory that there's a limited pool of people who are qualified to hold the top jobs in corporate America.
But such agreements are perennial sources of shareholder litigation when executives cash out after performing poorly.
"It generally has been a corporate governance issue on the radar screen for many shareholders for some time," said Jeff Mahoney, general counsel at the Council of Institutional Investors, which promotes good corporate governance practices.
Because of such shareholder discontent, the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act of 2010 requires companies to disclose the details of so-called golden parachutes and which executives have them, and requires shareholders to take nonbinding votes on executive compensation packages so they know what to expect.
The Council of Institutional Investors also recommends that companies beef up the language in change in control agreements to make sure they can be triggered only if an executive is released as part of a merger, and not because of poor performance.
As a requirement of receiving the TARP money, Whitney already has taken shareholder votes on executive compensation packages. And a description of the executive compensation packages in Whitney's annual proxy does not appear to have changed after Whitney borrowed TARP money.
But perhaps anticipating concerns like Cummings', Hancock notes in the draft proxy statement soliciting shareholder approval of its merger with Whitney that Whitney shareholders need to know that their interests are not identical to those of executives.
"Whitney shareholders should be aware that Whitney's executive officers and members of Whitney's board of directors may have interests in the merger that are different from, or in addition to, those of Whitney shareholders generally. Whitney's board of directors was aware of and considered these interests, among other matters, in evaluating and negotiating the merger agreement and the merger, and in recommending that the merger agreement be adopted and approved by Whitney's shareholders," reads the proxy filed by Hancock on Jan. 26.
Whitney's change of control agreements provide for a cash severance equal to three times an executive's average gross income for the highest of three of the past five calendar years. Each executive's severance also includes the bonus the executive would have received in the year of termination, a cash payment for the company's 401(k) matching contribution, a cash payment for the present value of three years of benefits that would have occurred in the company's pension, continued medical and life insurance benefits for the executive and his family, and transfer of ownership of any club membership or other executive perks.
Dayna Harris, vice president of Farient Advisors, an executive compensation consulting firm with offices in Los Angeles and New York, said a few things about Whitney's change in control agreements are unusual.
The cash compensation is based on annual gross income, and usually agreements would be more specific by linking it to salary and annual incentive. The metric of the highest of three of the past five years is also slightly more generous; it's more commonly just the average of the past three years.
Giving the chief executive officer a severance payment of three times salary an annual incentive is not unusual, Harris said, but that multiple typically declines to two or two and a half times for other executives.
The idea that the change of control agreement payment could be triggered as long as three years after the merger is consummated is also expansive. "Three years is pretty long," Harris said.
While it's difficult to figure out the value of the entire package, Whitney Chairman and Chief Executive John Hope, for example, would get a payment of $1.9 million in salary, plus other benefits, according to a summary of executive compensation from Whitney's 2010 proxy.
Whitney executives have not earned bonuses in recent years because of the TARP money and the performance of the bank.
Whitney officers also have been allowed to defer a certain amount of their compensation each year. Instead of those payments being paid out over time as previously specified, Whitney executives and directors will get a lump sum payment if they are terminated. Hope, for example, has $619,809 in deferred compensation available to him, according to draft merger proxy.
Whitney and Hancock say they can't comment on anything related to the merger except for what's in the filings.
In filings, the banks say they have not decided which executives will stay and which will go in the combined bank. The composition of the board of directors also hasn't been decided. Jonathan Briggs, managing director of the investment firm Chaffe & Associates, Inc., which advises a number of local banks, said the who-stays-and-who-goes debate is undoubtedly one of the biggest questions behind the scenes.
"They've already begun, I'm sure, and they'll continue through the whole approval process," Briggs said of the talks about management of the combined company.
This story was first published in The Times-Picayune. Rebecca Mowbray can be reached at [email protected]