Wednesday, October 5, 2011
But it doesn't always speak clearly; sometimes it insinuates.
The numbers demanded a double take. An incumbent lugging nearly two years' of bad headlines is rolling in the dough. His competitor, a decades-long civil servant with 22 years in the U.S. Air Force under his belt, is scraping by. I can't remember which campaign-finance report on the Ethics Board's website was more compelling - the handsome sum raised by Councilman Brandon Shelvin in one of Lafayette's poorest districts, or Carencro City Manager Lloyd Rochon lending his campaign four times more than it had taken in. Where Shelvin had generated more than $20,000 in contributions and had better than $15K in the bank, Rochon had less than $250 to spend after a single $500 contribution and $2,000 personal loan.
Wednesday, October 5, 2011
But it doesn't always speak clearly; sometimes it insinuates.
The numbers demanded a double take. An incumbent lugging nearly two years' of bad headlines is rolling in the dough. His competitor, a decades-long civil servant with 22 years in the U.S. Air Force under his belt, is scraping by. I can't remember which campaign-finance report on the Ethics Board's website was more compelling - the handsome sum raised by Councilman Brandon Shelvin in one of Lafayette's poorest districts, or Carencro City Manager Lloyd Rochon lending his campaign four times more than it had taken in. Where Shelvin had generated more than $20,000 in contributions and had better than $15K in the bank, Rochon had less than $250 to spend after a single $500 contribution and $2,000 personal loan.
It only hit me later like an antacid that Shelvin's reporting period spans Jan. 1 to Sept. 12; Rochon's runs from Sept. 8 - the day, late in the afternoon, he filed the paperwork to run - to Sept. 22. Rochon slipped into the race at the 11th hour when it was clear Shelvin would otherwise go unchallenged. Shelvin has been in campaign mode for months.
I spoke with Rochon Friday and he says his campaign coffer has bulged since he filed the report with Ethics - more than $5K in contributions in a little over a week. That says a lot in a race in which the challenger is a late entry. Rochon plans a series of media buys and will be canvassing a lot in this final stretch of the campaign.
But what do Shelvin's contributions reveal? We don't know what he's collected since he filed his report; the councilman has been unwilling to speak to this newspaper for more than a year. But his report suggests robust and enthusiastic support for his campaign. This is where the report insinuates.
Thirty-four of the 43 contributions Shelvin cites in the report - almost $16,500 or better than 80 percent of contributions during the nine-month reporting period - came in a single haul on July 21. That's the night a fundraiser for the candidate was held at a downtown restaurant - the night contributions, nearly a third of them up to the $1,000 maximum, came streaming in from people of means who neither live in District 3 nor, more than likely, share Shelvin's political views. The majority of contributors on July 21, in fact, are not Shelvin's constituents.
Indeed in some cases these contributions, regardless of date received, jibe with our understanding of how the political game is played. Sheriff Mike Neustrom, a fellow Democrat, needs support from the black community; his campaign committee contributed $250. So, too, do the contributions from Acadian Ambulance ($250) and Cox Communications ($250), corporate players that spread the wealth widely, evenly and commonly among opposing candidates, one of whom will win and could later be either an asset or a liability to their board room prerogatives.
But why would Denice Skinner, a member of the Lafayette Parish Republican Executive Committee, donate to a Democrat running for City-Parish Council? Or a developer who makes a bundle on low-income housing projects? That developer, Greg Gachassin, wrote a personal check to Shelvin for $500, as did two companies he owns - Park Group Construction and The Cartesian Company. That's $1,500 more or less from one contributor. Gachassin's physician brother Philip, and his father, Nick Jr., also contributed.
The list of contributors to the Shelvin campaign is reproduced on Page 5 along with some scathing analysis from Editorial Director Leslie Turk. What do that list and analysis tell us? Not much explicitly, but they imply a lot.